ANNE ASHWORTH PROPERTY EDITOR
Win a fitness package worth more than £3,000

WHAT exactly does a housing market downturn feel like? This is the question on the minds of many of the 12 million people with a mortgage who have never been up close and personal with such a reverse, having known only good times.
These strangers to slowdowns will now be looking for guidance to homeowners who have experienced this phenomenon at first hand. In the 20th century, there were four severe falls in house values: 1930-1933, 1973-1976, 1979-1980, and 1989-1993, when there was a decline of 13 per cent.
Homeowners who were children in the early 1930s can recount their memories of the Depression years; survivor accounts of the three subsequent slumps are also useful.
But only up to a point – although if you are interested in stories of relationships going wrong, you will be mesmerised by the tales of some of the unfortunate couples who bought places together in 1988. Within months they fell out of love and into negative equity. And, for the next four years, they rowed incessantly in claustrophobic studio flats they could not sell.
The common features of the four periods were recession combined with increases in unemployment and interest rates. Two of these conditions (recession and rising unemployment) do not currently apply, although the US market’s woes prove that a recession is not necessarily the precursor to a housing slump. There may indeed be a role reversal, with the property price collapse precipitating the recession.
Since history cannot provide an accurate guide to what lies ahead, forecasters currently predicting how the market will perform in 2008 are sometimes having to rely on guesswork. The depth of the problems resulting from the American sub-prime crisis is not yet clear, for example. It is certain that the resulting credit crunch has made UK mortgage lenders much meaner, but other side effects may still emerge that would have repercussions on both sides of the Atlantic.
The response of the nervier kind of buy-to-let investor to stagnating or sliding prices is also difficult to divine. As recently as 1993, the role of amateur landlord was much less popular than it is today. But even Capital Economics, the gloomiest guru collective, does not foresee a collapse in this sector. There are likely to be painful lessons, however, for those who invested unwisely in low-grade apartments in shoddy poorly located developments in Leeds, Liverpool and other cities. There are fears that these may go down in history as the properties most adversely affected in the downturn of 2008. For most other homeowners, the sensation of this slowdown seems likely to be more a ride down a gentle slope than a stomach-churning sudden descent.
GARAGES GO SKY HIGH
The prices fetched by garages are not yet a key indicator, but they do say something about confidence in the long-term prospects of the market in certain cities.
A double garage in Edinburgh sold for about £90,000 this week, a record. The space is suitable only for parking – it could not be transformed into a more valuable pied-à-terre for its new owners.
Huge potential for uplift, however, lies behind the $700,000 ($340,000) price of a garage in a block being built in the Chelsea district of Manhattan – which is an island of property price optimism amid the deepening sub-prime-induced misery elsewhere. Owners of apartments in this block will be able to drive into an elevator that will hoist them to garages on the same level as their luxury lofts. The security-conscious will be able to dodge “the hoods in the hood”. Those who are in the public eye will also be able to evade the photographers for whom celebrities forced to park in the street are ready prey.
As we report on pages 6-7, the garage feature is so popular that nearly three quarters of the $3.65 million-plus apartments are already sold. These values suggest faith in the continued availability of lucrative employment in Wall Street and the rest of New York. The jobs of paparazzi, however, may be under threat.
ESTATE OF MIND
Estate agents are called all sorts of things, some of them not that nice. Anyone who is less interested in the denigration of this trade than why they are so called (when most deal in semis rather than rather country piles) should know that the 200th anniversary approaches of their naming. The Times was involved.
Melanie Backe-Hansen, the historian at Chesterton, the estate agent, has uncovered the first use of the term “estate agent” in the edition of The Times of November 9, 1807. Formerly “house and estate agent” was the preferred phrase. The shorter name stuck and estate agents thrived to become businesses so successful that some are even able to employ their own in-house historians. anne.ashworth@thetimes.co.uk
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Having read even more comments, I am genuinely shocked by the amount of petty vitriol washing about. What makes people who want to make a bit of money for themselves out of property, to enjoy now, or plan for retirement, so evil?
Is the feeling that they distort the market, pushing houses out of reach for other people? Possibly, but these 'evil' investors often stretch themselves, taking considerable risks, in order to build a future for themselves.
Maybe if the bitter, and jealous contributors to these talk boards spent a bit more time summoning up the courage, and investigating ways to stretch themselves and grab their own piece of property, rather than praying for crash that is pretty unlikely, they'd have a bit more success.
Honestly, I thought we are supposed to be a nation that creates, not just sits about sniping at the success of others. Sorry guys, but no one is going to just hand you a 'reasonably priced' property, no matter what happens to the market.
Mark, London,
"WHAT exactly does a housing market downturn feel like?"
As I was working in the CAB in 1994-6 and Legal Aid thereafter until 2001, I will tell you:
Mortgagors expenses rose and rose as they got more and more in debt. Initially the interest and capital payments were paid by the state on Income Support but then that stopped for capital payments for the first 26 weeks (they were supposed to roll the debt over into any capital (and note I stress any capital). They would come to us too late and lenders were repossessing or they had already put their keys through the door and gone. Mortgagees were chasing them for a decade afterwards and tried to do this for longer based on the fact that the Mortgage Deed was exactly that, under Deed. In some fortunate cases, there was some council accomodation for people with families, now less likely, obviously. I think it is a case of Deja Vous. Please feel free to blog with any further queries. It is an interesting period we enter.
Pete Balchin, Solicitor , Bristol, UK
Which came first? The chicken of house price falls or the egg of recession?
What were the reasons for the falls from 1989? Credit was till then cheap and easy to get; people in their wisdom believed house prices would rise for ever and ever, amen. Then credit was squeezed, the inevitable result of the profligate years preceding. So overblown house prices fell (no money to support them), recession came because debt had to be paid off, and of course unemployment rose.
Causation is not something that seems to get much attention. But I think journalists who write on this subject should think a bit more about it, rather than say what everyone else is saying. Not a role reversal in this case: a role misunderstanding.
But at least we're not reading "Ah, but it's different this time" too often.
David, Guildford,
We were advised to put our Grade II listed cottage on at £680,000 at the beginning of September. A month later, the same agent advised we drop it down to £625,000. I have had 5 agents agreeing that the it is priced right, yet we have had only 2 viewings in 4 weeks and no sign of it selling. Albeit on the cosy side, it has bags of character, a 1/2 acre paddock, stables and gardens, overlooks a golf course and is within 10 minutes of M25/M1 and 5 minutes to mainline railway taking 25mins to Euston. We just cannot understand why nobody is interested
Alison Richards, Hemel Hempstead, Hertfordshire
Peter (Reading) is deadly accurate. 13%? I don't think so!. A friend bought in Cambridge in 1990 for 98,000 and sold for 60,000 in 1994! It lasted far longer than the press would have us believe. I watched a dilapidated house sell for 99,000 at auction in 1991. It was bought buy a builder eager to make a fast buck. He restored it beautifully, spending over 35,000, but couldn't sell it on. It eventually sold for 127,000 in 1997.
liz, ipswich,
"WHAT exactly does a housing market downturn feel like?"
For those who have not been sucked in by the hype and so mortgaged themselves to the hilt, it feels like nothing at all, same mortgage payments, same house, just a more sensible value. For those potential FTBs priced out for so long it feels like a long awaited relief.
Who will be hurt? Some estate agents and others in the property game and the BTL investors who foolishly belived that hoarding property was a one-way ticket to riches. Sorry, but these latter categories lie a long way down my sympathy list.
Clint Walker, Staffordshire, UK
13 % decline in 89-94? I sold in '89 a 3 bed x council for 76k and rented. By '94 an equivalent property was back down to 38k. I know this is just one example but how on earth do you come up with a slump figure of 13%? It was far worse than that and it's going to be far worse again. Tell 'em how it really is we can take it.
The top uk builders shares are down around 50% in the last 6 months. A time to buy- I think not.
peter, reading, berks