Gary Duncan: Economic View
Win a trip to the Ice Hotel in Lapland
As the grim economic news piles up ever higher, so the headlines grow ever more lurid. The latest, inspired by a gloom-laden assessment of prospects from the Ernst & Young Item Club, suggests that Britain faces an “economic horror movie”.
The trouble is that the analogy is scarcely excessive. If the economy's present woes really are spooling out like a horror flick, it is not one of those vaguely laughable schlock teen slasher productions, but a real certificate 18 spine-tingler that threatens us with psychological trauma. Even worse, we may be in only the early reels of an epic that will be chilling us all through this year and next.
Yet, ultimately, as with all horror movies, the terror will end and the lights will surely come back up. The question that should keep us on the edge of our seats is what fate will await Britain when the final reel of this downturn has played out. Where will we be left?
Although there may be a protracted saga of economic torment to endure in the meantime, one that will inevitably have its victims, the good news is that the eventual ending should actually herald a brighter future.
If Britain is to succumb to recession, we need to remember that such periods are a virtually inescapable feature of even the most successful capitalist economies, even a necessary one to purge the system of past excesses, inefficient practices and the weakest links among businesses.
We also need to remind ourselves that we emerged from the distress of past recessionary episodes to a brighter future in which Britons have never been more prosperous. We remain fortunate to live in an economy that, for all its notable and increasingly obvious shortcomings, is dynamic, flexible and possessed of immense potential.
That huge potential is spelt out in a fascinating new analysis by Goldman Sachs of how the league of leading world economies might look by the end of the next decade, and by the middle of the century.
Goldman's study, by Dominic Wilson and Raluca Dragusanu, builds on its past, prescient projections foreshadowing the rise of Brazil, Russia, India and China, which it famously dubbed the “Bric” economies. As before, it calculates that by 2020, China will have surged past Japan to become the world's No2 economy, ranked by GDP, and will be close on the heels of the United States. By then, India will have overtaken France and will be close to overhauling Britain in terms of the absolute size of its economy.
However, although Britain may have been surpassed in sheer economic scale by these giant new players, it too should have continued to grow and prosper over the next decade. Crucially, even if the UK is only the sixth-largest economy by 2020, its relatively modest population will share that increased wealth among a smaller number.
The upshot, Goldman concludes, is that, measured by GDP per head, it is little Britain that by then could well be the richest nation on Earth, eclipsing even America.
Propelled up the global rich list of countries by its oil and gas, Russia's economy may by then be bigger than Italy's and its citizens may be enjoying the living standards made possible by GDP per person of more than $20,000 (£10,000).
Well over a billion Chinese may have seen their national GDP per head reach almost $10,000. Yet by then the figure for the UK may already be over $55,000 (£27,000) for every Briton. Although Goldman reckons that by 2050 the US may be back on top in the rankings of GDP per head, the UK would still be in second place.
There are plenty of caveats, of course, and many things that could go wrong. Yet the prize that we might just grasp as a country is clear. Although we are fretting at present over a return to the dog days of the 1970s, when Britain was the “sick man of Europe”, the Seventies spirit that we could recapture could instead be that of the 1870s - a golden era of Victorian prosperity and national self-confidence.
These “great expectations” seem to raise two big questions. First, what can be done to ensure that this huge opportunity is grasped? Secondly, just how happy will we be as a nation if it is?
For all its present woes, over the past ten years the UK economy has indeed thrived. Yet, as Mervyn King, the Bank of England's Governor, has emphasised in his perceptive analysis of that “nice decade”, we had it pretty easy. Britain benefited from the fair wind of global low inflation and low interest rates, fostered by the decisive entry of China into the world economy and a global savings glut that made capital cheap and abundant. All of that allowed Gordon Brown to preside over good times that were as much in spite of his efforts as because of them.
In the more volatile and turbulent era on which we have embarked, ensuring that Britain seizes its opportunities will in large part mean ditching Mr Brown's mistaken conviction that the necessary entrepreneurialism, innovation and productivity to drive prosperity can be unleashed by the dead hand of the state pulling levers in Whitehall. Ten years of the Prime Minister's quest for the holy grail of higher productivity have proved largely fruitless. The spirit of enterprise that Mr Brown has claimed to want to foster has meanwhile been stifled by a choking combination of ever-rising business taxes and red tape. All of that must be thrown into reverse.
None of this means that unleashing the free market offers a simple prescription to allow Britain to fulfil the economic promise mapped out by Goldman. The present global financial turmoil created by parts of Wall Street and the City is a stark reminder that markets alone are not enough.
Nor will ensuring that Britain secures its clear potential for prosperity guarantee national happiness. Wealth may help, but alone is clearly neither necessary nor sufficient to ensure the security and contentment that we all crave. That is where the even greater challenge of political leadership will lie in the years to come. At least, though, we can take comfort amid the present “horrors” that a happy ending remains the most likely conclusion.
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2005 / 55
£59,500
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Energy security is the key! Our leaders have had "their heads in the sand" over the stark reality of international competition for resources and blackmail from a resurgent Russia. Economic renewable hydrogen looks a good way out of this mess, uniquely developed & demonstrated by UK's ITM Power Plc
CHP, Malmesbury,
You have got to be kidding... right?
Harvey, London,
I see the Panglossian faction are out in strength. To any objective observer the UK is in secular decline. The results from the belief that we don't need to make anything anymore and that the rest of the world owes us a living. Economic forecasts! You'd do better listing to the cabbie.
Frank, London, UK
It's Monday - I've been to Liverpool for the Tall Ships extravaganza. Despite what the pundits say, the city was buzzing, the restaurants were packed out, and the waiting staff where I had lunch were practically on their knees trying to keep up. There may be those who don't care to hear this !
Shirley Bowen, Blackpool, UK
Yes, I agree. I travel a lot in Europe and most other European countries are visibly less affluent. I'm not so optimistic that India and China won't begin to outbid us on natural resources though.
Tony, rochester, UK
This article is a science fiction treatise. Is Gary developing a paralell world philosophy and if so please distinguish between reality and fiction a singular lack of which has underpinned the Blair/Brown experiment on how to ruin a Country whilst whistling things can only get better.
philip, Ipswich,
"an economy that, for all its notable and increasingly obvious shortcomings, is dynamic, flexible ... "
Some of us are. Namely those that endure unemployment while management fail, or pay additional taxes to bail badly run companies out, or endure ever increasing costs without offset.
Joe, Geelong, VIC Australia
So now we have to look forward to 2050 - when today's 25 year old when will be 67.
As the author writes "There are plenty of caveats, of course, and many things that could go wrong."
Imagine writing this in 1908...
Hendrik Heijmans, Penang, Malaysia
Projection charts need to be clearer as to whether this is PPP or measured at current market exchange rate, also would question the figures for both Canada and the US, would expect US despite slower per capita growth to be at least 10% wealthier than the U.K. as it is currently about 20% richer.
Gareth Kendall, Maidstone, UK
Stupid forecast by economists.
Oil will continue to ratchet up unless there is a worldwide depression - not good. We are a dependency society with a diminishing useful workforce, many of whom want to get out: me!
The future is more anger and civil disturbance, and economic collapse.
C Smith, Norwich, Norfolk
Why is everyone in Britain so negative? We live in a wealthy country (as indicated by the high GDP per capita) where even the poorest in society have a good level of state support to fall back on. Living standards have risen rapidly for decadesand will remain high even after a possible recession.
Will, Edinburgh,
Too rosy a picture. We continue to tax productive people out of our economy, whilst growing the underclass on benefits. Our society is becoming evermore polarised in terms of wealth. Without the middle class glue society will break down & there will be an Orwellian future for UK Plc!!!
Steve Marchant, Newton Abbot, UK
Flexible and dinamic economy? No sir! WE, the workers of this country are flexible, dinamic and, above all, CHEAP. So, tell me about the super rich now. Are they going to keep their tax break?
Fabio C, London, UK
'Alistair?'
'Yes, Gordon.'
'Can we get a few financial journalists to say how things are going to be OK, no matter what?'
'Well, yes. But they've been saying that all along, Gordon.'
'Well, let them do more of it. Speak to as many as you can about it.'
'But, Gordon.'
'See this machine gun?'
john problem, winchester, uk
Insourcing manufacturing and introducing import tariffs for goods manufactured outside the EU would be a good way to rebuild the economy. If this sounds too 'protectionist' for free market gurus, then how do they suppose China and the USA for that matter built their economies in the first place?
Paul, Coventry,
I have run a business in the real economy for 13 years, I agree 100%. The Thatcher revolution of the 1980s was profound and robust. Despite this dreadful Governmen., the UK is well placed to exploit the huge opportunities ahead. Down-turns are a temporary and necessary inconvenience.
Ray, Cambridge, UK
A country lacking natural resources makes money by (a) cheap labour, (b) specialised services or (c) trading/arbitrage. Read China, Switzerland, Singapore respectively. The UK has relied on financial services to the detriment of the rest of the economy. It's time to change.
John Stobart, O, UK
Economy might be dynamic and flexible, but one's salary and
(later) pension isn't - as the average people are finding out to their consternation.
lena, vienna, austria
GDP per head is a remarkably stupid way of measuring an economy's performance because it disguises the wealth gap.
Scamp, Aberdeenshire, Scotland
Perhaps a publisher could give Goldman Sachs a book deal... this fantasy is quite possibly more far fetched than Harry Potter, and some might say equally amusing.
But then maybe I'm being far too cynical and indeed we are simply waiting for the Hogwarts Express to reveal itself...
Mark, London,
What about measuring debt per person and subtracting this from GDP per head.Where would the US or UK rank?
stephen hulton, eure, france
Actually GDP per head is a very good way to measure wealth, because even with a "wealth gap" - boo-hoo, by the way - it tells you what is available for future investment. And thats where your children's jobs will come from. Not from trying to equalise wealth.
jon livesey, Sunnyvale, CA/USA
Oil available for export is likely to be around 35million barrels by 2018, down from 87 today.
The inflated ponzi schemes in the UK and US are unwinding, together with bloated financial service sectors.
The UK has massive debts and is in deficit before the recession.
Absurd and baseless forecasts.
David Martin, Bristol,